Annuities vs. Life Insurance: Key Differences

Annuities and life insurance are financial products that serve distinct purposes, though both involve an agreement with an insurance company. Annuities are designed to provide a stream of income, often in retirement, while life insurance offers a death benefit to beneficiaries in exchange for premiums. The key differences lie in their primary goals: annuities focus on income security for the policyholder, whereas life insurance prioritizes financial protection for loved ones after the policyholder’s passing. Comparing annuities vs. life insurance and understanding the differences between them can help you better plan for your own needs.

A financial advisor can help you create a financial plan for your retirement needs and goals. Connect with an advisor today.

What Is an Annuity?

An annuity is a financial contract with an insurance company designed to provide a steady income, typically during retirement. In exchange for a lump sum payment or a series of contributions, the annuity guarantees regular payouts starting at a specified time. There are various types of annuities, with fixed, variable, and indexed annuities being among the most common.

Fixed annuities: Offer a guaranteed interest rate and predictable income, making them appealing to conservative investors seeking stability.
Variable annuities: Allow you to choose investments within the contract, with returns tied to the performance of those investments. While this carries more risk, it offers potential for higher gains.
Indexed annuities: Provide returns linked to a specific market index, such as the S&P 500, offering a middle ground between fixed and variable options.

Fixed annuities are often preferred by risk-averse individuals who prioritize financial security, while younger or more experienced investors may gravitate toward variable annuities for the potential of higher returns. Indexed annuities can appeal to those seeking a balance between risk and reward.

Pros and Cons of an Annuity

Annuities can offer unique benefits for retirement planning, but they also come with drawbacks that may affect their overall appeal. Below is a breakdown of the pros and cons to consider:

Benefits

Flexibility: Annuities don’t have contribution limits like a 401(k) or IRA, allowing for larger deposits.
Tax-deferred growth: Funds in an annuity grow tax-deferred, which can boost savings over time.
Late retirement planning: They can be useful for individuals who start saving for retirement later in life, as they allow for larger, tax-deferred contributions.

Drawbacks

High fees: Annuities often come with high fees, including commissions for insurance brokers that can reach up to 10% of the contract value.
Surrender fees: Early withdrawals may incur surrender charges, which can reduce overall returns.
Potentially lower returns: In some cases, other retirement savings vehicles, like an IRA, may offer better long-term growth potential without the added fees and restrictions.

What Is Life Insurance?

SmartAsset: Annuities vs. Life Insurance

Life insurance is a contract between an individual and an insurance provider, guaranteeing a lump-sum payment, referred to as a death benefit, to the named beneficiaries after the policyholder’s death. In exchange, the policyholder pays premiums to the insurer. The death benefit can be used for various purposes, such as covering funeral costs, paying off debts, or providing financial support to loved ones.

There are two main types of life insurance: term life insurance and permanent life insurance.

Term life insurance: Coverage runs for a fixed period, such as 10, 20 or 30 years, and is often more affordable.
Permanent life insurance: Includes whole and universal life policies, offering lifelong coverage as long as premiums are paid, with the added benefit of a cash value component.

Many permanent policies build cash value over time, which policyholders can access for loans or withdrawals. Some also include living benefits, such as coverage for critical care needs. However, it’s important to note that any remaining cash value typically reverts to the insurer upon the policyholder’s death, leaving only the death benefit for beneficiaries. Most life insurance benefits are tax-free, offering financial peace of mind and flexibility.

Pros and Cons of Life Insurance

Life insurance offers valuable benefits, but it also has potential drawbacks that should be carefully considered. Here’s a breakdown of the advantages and disadvantages:

Benefits

Tax-free withdrawals: Many policies allow tax-free withdrawals or loans against the cash value, depending on the contract terms.
Family protection: Life insurance provides financial security for loved ones in the event of the policyholder’s death, offering peace of mind.
Tax-deferred growth: Like annuities, the assets within the policy grow tax-deferred over time.

Drawbacks

High fees: Policies can come with significant maintenance and administrative fees, which may reduce the overall value.
Costly premiums: Premium payments can become burdensome over time, leading some policyholders to cancel their contracts.
Loss of contributions: Canceling a policy may result in the loss of all contributions, potentially leaving the policyholder with little to no return compared to other investment options like retirement accounts.

Key Differences

Annuities and life insurance serve fundamentally different financial goals. Annuities are designed to provide income to the policyholder, often during retirement, by converting a lump sum or series of payments into a steady stream of payouts. In contrast, life insurance focuses on creating a financial safety net for beneficiaries, offering a death benefit to provide security after the policyholder’s passing.

The way these products are structured also sets them apart. Annuities are primarily income-focused and are often used as a tool to manage longevity risk, ensuring that the policyholder doesn’t outlive their savings. They typically come with features like guaranteed payouts and tax-deferred growth. Life insurance, however, centers around wealth protection and legacy planning. Policies like whole or universal life insurance may include cash value components, but their primary purpose remains to provide financial support to loved ones.

Additionally, fees and taxation differ significantly. Annuities often involve higher upfront costs and surrender charges, while life insurance premiums can vary based on age, health, and policy type.

How to Select the Right Policy

The most important factor in determining which product is right for you is to decide the goal of the contract. For example, if you want to make sure your children are taken care of and pay for funeral expenses when you die, consider some form of life insurance.

Conversely, if you want a secure stream of income in retirement you may consider an annuity since it offers tax-deferred savings and steady income. Both plans may provide some form of a death benefit, but each option may vary drastically depending on what plan you’re considering. If you’re still unsure, you may want to consult a financial advisor who can help you review all your options.

Bottom Line

Annuities and life insurance each play unique roles in financial planning, catering to different priorities and life stages. While annuities are designed to provide a reliable income stream during retirement, life insurance focuses on safeguarding your loved ones’ financial future. Understanding the structure, benefits, and potential drawbacks of these products can help you align them with your specific financial goals. Whether you’re aiming to secure steady retirement income or protect your family’s well-being, these tools offer flexible solutions tailored to diverse needs.

Tips for Retirement Planning

Consider talking to a financial advisor about annuities and life insurance, and whether either should be part of your retirement plan. SmartAsset’s free tool matches you with vetted financial advisors who serve your area, and you can have a free introductory call with your advisor matches to decide which one you feel is right for you. If you’re ready to find an advisor who can help you achieve your financial goals, get started now.
Before you get an annuity or a life insurance policy, you should know how much money you’ll need in retirement and whether you’re on pace to meet your goals. Get an estimate with SmartAsset’s free retirement calculator.