How Does a 1035 Exchange Work?

When it comes to managing your insurance or annuity investments, a 1035 exchange offers a valuable strategy that many policyholders don’t fully understand. This IRS provision allows you to transfer funds from one life insurance policy, annuity contract, or endowment to another without triggering immediate tax consequences. Essentially, a 1035 exchange works by preserving your investment’s tax-deferred status while giving you the flexibility to switch to a more advantageous policy.

If you have questions about tax maneuvers like this one, consider speaking with a financial advisor today.

What Is a 1035 Exchange?

A 1035 exchange, or like-kind exchange, is a legal way to swap one financial product of like kind without triggering tax on any investment gains associated with the original contract.

This applies to several types of financial accounts:

Insurance policies
Annuity
Endowment
Long-term care

The IRS allows these exchanges under Section 1035 of the Internal Revenue Code. These exchanges are tax deferments, which are distinct from tax deductions and credits.

That doesn’t mean the exchange is completely tax-free, however. If annuity payments are taxable, then the tax is simply deferred until you begin receiving payments from it.

A 1035 exchange can be a useful tax loophole if you want to use an annuity or life insurance policy to plan your estate but decide at some point that the one you have no longer fits your needs.

How a 1035 Exchange Works

A 1035 exchange may sound complicated, but it’s a simple way to ensure that you have the right annuity or life insurance product that fits your needs.

For example, say you have a life insurance policy. To do a 1035 exchange, you would replace that policy with a new life insurance policy.

In the case of an annuity, the annuitant, or person receiving payments from the annuity, must remain the same. With a life insurance exchange, you would still be the covered person, but you could change the beneficiary on the policy.

IRS Stipulations

When you make the exchange, you incur no taxes on any investment gains associated with the swap. However, there are a couple of rules the IRS requires you to follow.

It Must Be an Even Trade

When a 1035 exchange involves life insurance, you must make an even trade in swapping out your old policy for a new one. You can’t cash out the old policy and use the money to buy a new one.

This can limit your options for your future policy or contract.

1035 Exchanges Only Work Certain Ways

For example, you can exchange life insurance for life insurance or life insurance for a non-qualified annuity. However, you can’t exchange a non-qualified annuity for a life insurance policy.

Also, life insurance policies and non-qualified annuities may be exchanged for traditional and hybrid qualified long-term care products.

Surrendering May Equal Ordinary Income

Say you surrender a life insurance policy without a 1035 exchange and replace it with a new policy or annuity.

Any gains associated with your original contract are now considered ordinary income. This is something to keep in mind if you have a permanent life insurance policy that allows you to build cash value through investments.

It’s also important to remember that any other exchanges of life insurance, annuities or endowments that don’t fit the IRS rules above will not enjoy tax-advantaged status.

Click Your State to Get Matched With Financial Advisors That Serve Your Area

Choose your state and answer some questions to get matched with up to three fiduciary advisors that serve your area.

Benefits of Using a 1035 Exchange

Paper umbrella over a paper house and family.

The primary advantage of using a 1035 exchange to change your life insurance policy or annuity choices is to avoid triggering taxes on those transactions.

There are various scenarios in which exchanging policies or annuity contracts might make sense:

You need more life insurance coverage than you currently have.
You want to change the type of life insurance policy you have.
You’re looking for an annuity contract with lower fees.
You want to restructure your annuity payments.
You need a completely different type of annuity.

As long as you’re exchanging contracts within IRS guidelines, you won’t have to worry about those events being taxable to you.

You may, however, still have to pay a surrender charge to trade one annuity contract or life insurance policy for another. These charges are penalties for canceling your contract and vary in cost and due dates. They may be a flat fee or a percentage of the amount you paid into the contract.

Your life insurance company or annuity provider may waive any surrender charges if you’re exchanging policies or contracts with the same company. However, if you’re moving your policy or contract to a brand-new company, you may have to factor in the surrender cost as part of the process.

What to Consider Before Doing a 1035 Exchange

If you’re considering exchanging one life insurance policy or annuity for another, be sure to look at the bigger picture. Consider how it may impact your financial plan.

Life Insurance Considerations

For example, ask yourself these questions with a life insurance exchange:

Will my current health status affect my ability to qualify for a new policy?
What’s the waiting period for the new policy before death benefits can be paid?
Is it possible that my rates will increase based on age or health?
Are there any outstanding loans on the policy that must be repaid before making an exchange?
Will a new policy offer a better death benefit or additional features, such as an accelerated death benefit or long-term care riders?

Annuity Considerations

With an annuity, the questions to ask are a little different:

Would a new annuity be more cost-friendly in terms of lower fees?
Will the structure of my annuity payments change?
Does a new annuity offer the potential for better investment returns?
Does an annuity still fit my estate and retirement planning needs?
Will I pay a surrender fee to exchange annuities?

Remember, when exchanging life insurance or an annuity, you must remain the owner of the policy or contract. If the ownership of either one changes, the 1035 exchange tax rules no longer apply.

When a 1035 Exchange May Not Be Worth It

A 1035 exchange can preserve the tax-deferred status of an insurance policy or annuity, but that does not mean an exchange makes financial sense. In some cases, the costs of switching can outweigh the potential benefits.

Surrender Charges

One of the biggest factors is the surrender charge.

Many annuities and life insurance policies impose fees for withdrawing or transferring money during the early years of the contract. Those charges can consume a meaningful portion of the account value.

These fees make it difficult for a new policy’s lower fees or improved features to offset the cost of leaving the old one.

Health

For life insurance owners, health can be another obstacle.

A policy purchased years ago may have been issued when you were younger and healthier. If your health has deteriorated since then, replacing the policy could result in higher premiums, less favorable terms or even a rejection.

In some cases, keeping an older policy may be more valuable than obtaining a newer one with updated features.

Benefits

Annuity owners should also look closely at the benefits built into their existing contract.

Some older annuities include guaranteed interest rates, income riders or withdrawal benefits that are difficult or impossible to replicate today. Giving up those guarantees in exchange for lower fees may not be a favorable trade if the existing benefits are still valuable.

Timing

The timing of the exchange matters, as well.

Moving into a new annuity often means starting over with a new surrender period and a new schedule of contract restrictions. Investors who expect to need access to their money in the near future may find that a new contract limits their flexibility.

A 1035 exchange can be a powerful planning tool, but the tax deferral is only one piece of the analysis. Before making a change, compare the costs, guarantees, fees and policy features on both sides of the transaction.

The best exchange is not necessarily the one with the newest contract, but the one that leaves you in a stronger financial position overall.

Bottom Line

Understanding how a 1035 exchange works can save you significant tax liability when transferring between insurance policies. This IRS provision allows policyholders to exchange one insurance contract for another without immediate taxation on any investment gains. Remember that while the process offers valuable tax advantages, it’s not without limitations. Exchanges must occur between similar policy types, and you cannot receive funds directly during the transfer. By understanding these key aspects of how a 1035 exchange works, you can make informed decisions about managing your insurance assets while preserving tax-advantaged status.

Retirement Planning Tips

Consider talking to a financial advisor about the tax implications of a 1035 exchange or other tax moves. Finding a financial advisor doesn’t have to be hard. SmartAsset’s free tool matches you with vetted financial advisors who serve your area, and you can have a free introductory call with your advisor matches to decide which one you feel is right for you. If you’re ready to find an advisor who can help you achieve your financial goals, get started now.
When comparing annuities, take time to look at the details. That includes not only the annuity’s terms and costs but the quality of the company that’s issuing the annuity. If a company isn’t financially healthy, it’s possible that they may not be able to make your annuity payments when the time comes.