Fee-based advisors charge a set fee for their services, either hourly, by project, or as a percentage of assets under management. This model can offer transparency and reduce potential conflicts of interest, as the advisor’s income isn’t tied to selling specific products. Commission-based advisors, by comparison, can earn money through commissions on the financial products they sell, such as mutual funds or insurance policies. While this can sometimes result in lower upfront costs for the client, it may also lead to potential bias toward recommending a higher-commission products.
If you’re not sure which advisor to choose, consider using SmartAsset’s free tool to get matched with potential advisors for your situation.
What Is a Fee-Based Financial Advisor?
A fee-based financial advisor is a professional who provides financial planning and investment management services and is compensated through a combination of fees and commissions. Unlike fee-only advisors, who earn solely from client fees and have no financial incentives tied to specific products, fee-based advisors have a more hybrid compensation structure.
The primary distinguishing feature of a fee-based financial advisor is their dual compensation model. These advisors charge clients fees for their services, which might include hourly rates, flat fees for specific projects, or a percentage of assets under management (AUM). In addition to these fees, they can also earn commissions from the sale of financial products, such as insurance policies, mutual funds or annuities.
One of the key considerations for potential clients is the possibility of conflicts of interest. Because fee-based advisors can earn commissions from the sale of financial products, there might be an incentive to recommend products that provide higher commissions rather than those that are necessarily in the client’s best interest. However, many fee-based advisors only have a legal fiduciary duty when acting in their “fee” capacity. And this doesn’t apply when they are selling products.
What Is a Commission-Based Financial Advisor?
Commission-based financial advisors serve clients by providing financial advice and recommending investment strategies that align with the client’s financial goals. Their primary aim is to help clients make informed decisions about their money, whether it’s for retirement planning, college savings or general investment purposes.
Additionally, commission-based financial advisors earn their income through commissions on the financial products they sell to clients. Unlike fee-only advisors who can charge a percentage of assets under management and a flat rate or hourly fee, commission-based advisors receive a percentage of the sales they generate, such as mutual funds, insurance policies, or other investment products.
The key aspect of a commission-based financial advisor’s compensation is that they earn money through the products they sell. For example, if they recommend a particular mutual fund, they might earn a commission based on the amount of money the client invests in that fund. This commission is often a percentage of the investment or a flat fee paid by the financial product provider.
Major Differences Between Fee- and Commission-Based Advisors
Key differences revolve around how fee- and commission-based advisors are compensated, which influences their incentives, potential conflicts of interest and the type of advice they might offer.
Fee-Based Financial Advisors
Here are some of the most important aspects of fee-based advisors:
- Fees: They earn money through a combination of fees paid by clients. These fees can be hourly rates, flat fees for specific services, or a percentage of assets under management (AUM).
- Client-centric: Their primary incentive is to provide advice that is in the best interest of their clients, as their income is not tied to selling specific financial products.
- Transparency: Because they charge a fee for their advice, they may offer more transparent and unbiased recommendations.
- Fewer conflicts: Since their compensation is not dependent on product sales, there is generally less potential for conflicts of interest compared to commission-based advisors.
Commission-Based Financial Advisors
Here are some of the most important aspects of commission-based financial advisors:
- Commissions: They earn money through commissions from the sale of financial products such as mutual funds, insurance policies and annuities.
- Product sales: Their primary incentive is to sell financial products, which can lead to a conflict of interest as their income depends on the volume and type of products sold.
- Potential bias: They may be biased towards recommending products that offer higher commissions, even if they are not the best fit for the client.
- Higher conflicts: There is a higher potential for conflicts of interest due to the direct link between their compensation and the sale of financial products.
Choosing between these types of advisors depends on your financial needs, preferences for how advice is compensated and your comfort level with potential conflicts of interest.
How to Know Which Advisor You Should Work With
Fee-based advisors may charge a fee for their services (in addition to a commission), and that fee could be structured as hourly fees, flat fees, or a percentage of assets under management. This model often appeals to those who prefer transparent, predictable costs and value comprehensive, ongoing advice.
Commission-based advisors, on the other hand, earn their income through the sale of financial products, such as mutual funds, insurance policies, or annuities. This model may be suitable for individuals who do not require continuous financial planning but need specific investment or insurance products. Commission-based advisors can be cost-effective if you are looking for one-time transactions or occasional advice.
However, you should make sure that the advisor’s recommendations align with your financial goals and not just their commission incentives. When deciding between the two, consider your financial needs, preferences for advisor compensation and the level of ongoing support you desire.
Bottom Line
The choice between fee-based and commission-based financial advisors hinges on individual financial goals, preferences and the level of transparency desired. Investors should seek advisors who are transparent about their compensation models, fully disclose potential conflicts of interest, and have a strong fiduciary commitment. By understanding key compensation model differences and evaluating personal financial needs, investors can make informed decisions that support their long-term financial well-being.
Tips for Financial Planning
- A financial advisor can help you find a balance in your finances to reach your long-term financial goals. Finding a financial advisor doesn’t have to be hard. SmartAsset’s free tool matches you with up to three vetted financial advisors who serve your area, and you can have a free introductory call with your advisor matches to decide which one you feel is right for you. If you’re ready to find an advisor who can help you achieve your financial goals, get started now.
- To help you better understand your own risk profile, consider using a free asset allocation calculator.
Photo credit: ©iStock.com/visualspace, ©iStock.com/Jay Yuno, ©iStock.com/DMP