8 Signs It's Time to Change Financial Advisors

Sometimes, the question is not can you change financial advisors, but rather, should you change financial advisors? Perhaps you have noticed a lack of communication or feel like your goals are not fully understood. Maybe there are red flags like high fees or ethical concerns. Whatever the reason, it could be time to reassess the relationship. These are eight signs that it is time to seek a new financial advisor who better aligns with your needs and expectations.

SmartAsset can help you find a fiduciary financial advisor who’s required to act in your best interests.

Can You Change Financial Advisors?

Yes, you are absolutely allowed to change financial advisors at any time. There are no legal or regulatory restrictions preventing you from making this switch, as you have the right to choose who manages your financial portfolio.

However, before making the decision, there are several important factors to consider.

Transfer fees: Some firms may charge fees for transferring accounts, so it’s important to ask about any potential costs before making the switch.
Account transition: Ensure a smooth transition by confirming how long the process will take and if your new advisor will handle the transfer of assets on your behalf.
Tax implications: Selling investments during the transfer may trigger capital gains taxes, so you should consult with both your current and new advisors to mitigate tax liability.
Investment strategy alignment: Make sure your new advisor’s investment philosophy aligns with your financial goals and risk tolerance.
Communication and reporting: Clarify how often the new advisor will communicate with you and provide reports on your portfolio’s performance.

8 Signs It’s Time to Change Financial Advisors

Not all relationships last forever. These are eight signs it is time to change financial advisors:

1. Ethical Concerns

Ethical concerns may arise if your financial advisor has disclosures of rule violations, civil penalties or even a criminal history. Any of these issues can undermine the trust you place in your advisor and raise questions about integrity. Past unethical behavior or legal issues could indicate that your advisor is not acting in your best interest and has failed to follow the code of ethics. This might suggest it is time to find a new advisor with higher ethical standards.

2. Lack of Communication

A financial advisor should keep you updated on your investments and any changes in your financial plan. If you find that your advisor is difficult to reach or fails to respond promptly to your inquiries, it may be a sign that they are not prioritizing your needs. Consistent and open communication is critical to a successful client-advisor relationship, and a lack of it could indicate it’s time to find someone more attentive to your concerns.

3. Misaligned Goals and Strategies

Your financial advisor should understand and support your financial goals. You may be concerned if it seems like your advisor’s strategies are not aligned with your objectives, or you feel pushed toward investments that don’t match your risk tolerance or long-term plans. An advisor should tailor their advice to your specific situation, and if the approach does not reflect your goals, it might be time to seek someone who better understands your financial aspirations.

4. High Fees

While financial advisors deserve fair compensation, excessive fees can erode your investment returns over time. If the cost of your advisor’s services is higher than average, or you are charged for services that do not add significant value, it might be worth reconsidering the relationship. High costs can significantly impact your long-term financial progress, and switching to an advisor with a more transparent and reasonable fee structure could be beneficial.

5. Poor Performance

If your portfolio consistently underperforms the market or falls short of meeting your financial goals, it might be time to reassess whether your financial advisor is effectively managing your investments. While occasional dips are normal, a pattern of poor performance could indicate a lack of expertise or misaligned strategies. It may be prudent to seek an advisor with a better track record who can help you achieve more consistent, positive outcomes.

6. Personality Mismatch

A successful relationship with a financial advisor relies not only on expertise but also on personal rapport. If you find that you consistently clash with your advisor, feel uncomfortable discussing your finances or sense that they do not fully respect your opinions and preferences, it could be a sign of a personality mismatch. In such cases, finding an advisor with whom you can build a more trusting and collaborative relationship might lead to better financial outcomes.

7. Conflicts of Interest

Financial advisors should act in your best interest, but conflicts of interest can sometimes get in the way. If your advisor receives commissions or incentives for recommending certain products or prioritizes their own financial gain over your needs, it could lead to biased advice. These conflicts may compromise the objectivity of the guidance you receive, making it necessary to seek out an advisor who operates with greater impartiality and transparency.

8. Not Enough Transparency

Transparency is crucial in any financial advisory relationship. If your advisor is vague about their fees, reluctant to explain investment decisions or unwilling to provide clear, detailed reports on your portfolio’s performance, it could be a sign that they are not being fully open with you. A lack of transparency can erode trust and make it difficult for you to feel confident in your financial decisions. Seeking an advisor who is more forthcoming and transparent may help restore your peace of mind.

Click Your State to Get Matched With Financial Advisors That Serve Your Area

Choose your state and answer some questions to get matched with up to three fiduciary advisors that serve your area.

How to Have a Conversation With Your Advisor Before Switching

Switching advisors involves real costs and disruption, and in many cases it is worth attempting a direct conversation before committing to that path. Fee concerns, communication gaps and strategy misalignment are all issues that a good advisor should be willing to address when raised clearly and directly. Skipping that step and walking away without giving the advisor a chance to respond means you may end up repeating the same frustrations with someone new.

Going into the conversation with specific examples rather than general complaints makes it more productive. Telling an advisor that you feel out of the loop is harder to act on than pointing out that you have not received a portfolio review in eighteen months or that your last three emails took two weeks to receive a response. Concrete examples give the advisor something to respond to and make it easier to evaluate whether their answer is satisfactory.

The way an advisor responds to direct feedback is itself useful information. An advisor who listens carefully, acknowledges the concern and proposes a specific change is demonstrating the kind of professionalism worth giving another chance. One who becomes defensive, minimizes the issue or offers vague assurances without any concrete follow-through is telling you something important about how the relationship will continue.

Some issues do not warrant a conversation before leaving. If your research has turned up ethical violations, regulatory actions or a pattern of behavior that suggests the advisor has been acting against your interests, there is little a conversation can resolve. The same applies to confirmed conflicts of interest where the advisor’s compensation structure is fundamentally misaligned with your needs. In those situations, moving on promptly is the more appropriate response.

If you do have the conversation and reach an agreement on changes, documenting what was discussed and what was committed to is a practical step. A brief follow-up email summarizing the key points creates a record that is useful if the same problems resurface. It also signals that you are paying close attention, which on its own can prompt a more attentive response from an advisor who may have been taking the relationship for granted.

How to Change Financial Advisors

An unhappy client talks to his financial advisor on the phone.

When you are ready to change financial advisors, following a structured process can help ensure a smooth transition and safeguard your financial interests. Following these steps will help guide you through the process:

Review your current agreement. Check your contract to understand any potential penalties or required notice periods for terminating your relationship with your current advisor.
Research new advisors. Look for a new advisor who better aligns with your financial goals and values. If you need help finding a new advisor, SmartAsset can match you with up to three vetted financial advisors who serve your area.
Notify your current advisor. Provide formal notice to your current advisor in writing. Be clear about your decision, and ask for a summary of any pending matters.
Transfer your assets. Coordinate with your new advisor to transfer your accounts and investments. They can help ensure a smooth transition while minimizing any disruptions to your financial plan.
Monitor the transition. Keep an eye on your accounts during the transition to ensure everything is transferred correctly and nothing is missed.
Establish communication. Set clear expectations with your new advisor regarding communication, goals and the ongoing management of your financial plan.

Building a Relationship With a New Advisor

Once you have moved on from your previous advisor, the first step with your new advisor is to set clear expectations. Discuss how often you want to meet, what form of communication you prefer and how performance reports will be shared. Establishing these details early helps avoid the same frustrations that may have led you to switch in the first place.

It is also important to review your financial goals together. A new advisor should take time to understand your retirement plans, tax situation, estate needs and risk tolerance. By walking through these areas in detail, you create a shared roadmap that ensures both of you are working toward the same objectives.

During the transition, ask your new advisor to review your current investments and identify whether adjustments are needed. This may involve rebalancing your portfolio, shifting tax strategies or consolidating accounts. These steps allow your new advisor to align your portfolio with your long-term plan while minimizing unnecessary costs or risks.

Finally, treat the first year as a trial period. Monitor whether the advisor delivers on communication, transparency and alignment with your goals. A good relationship will be built on trust and consistency, so pay attention to whether you feel informed and confident in the advice you receive.

Bottom Line

Angry clients confront their financial advisor about investment decisions that don't align with their financial goals.

Finding a professional who operates with transparency and keeps your financial interests at the center of the relationship is not a luxury. It is the baseline of what a good advisory relationship should deliver. When those elements are absent, it is worth asking whether the relationship is still serving you.

“The most important thing about working with a financial advisor is that they are addressing your needs. If that’s not the case, it’s time to explore other options,” said Brandon Renfro, CFP®, RICP, EA.

Brandon Renfro, CFP®, RICP, EA, provided the quote used in this article. Please note that Brandon is not a participant in SmartAsset AMP, is not an employee of SmartAsset and has been compensated. The opinion voiced in the quote is for general information only and is not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations.

Tips for Finding a Financial Advisor

Before choosing a financial advisor, research the advisor’s background and credentials through resources like the SEC’s Investment Adviser Public Disclosure (IAPD) website or FINRA’s BrokerCheck. These platforms provide information about the advisor’s work history, certifications and any disciplinary actions. You can also read reviews or ask for referrals from trusted sources to ensure the advisor has a solid reputation for reliability and trustworthiness.
Finding a financial advisor doesn’t have to be hard. SmartAsset’s free tool matches you with vetted financial advisors who serve your area, and you can have a free introductory call with your advisor matches to decide which one you feel is right for you. If you’re ready to find an advisor who can help you achieve your financial goals, get started now.