Warren Buffett S&P 500: Index Fund Investment Strategy

Warren Buffett has long advocated low-cost S&P 500 index funds for nonprofessional investors. Instead of trying to identify individual winners or time the market, this approach offers exposure to hundreds of large U.S. companies while limiting costs that could otherwise reduce long-term compounded returns.

A financial advisor can help you decide whether an index-based investment strategy aligns with your goals, risk tolerance and time horizon.

Why Warren Buffett Recommends S&P 500 Index Funds

Buffett’s approach is based partly on the idea that most nonprofessional investors do not need to predict which individual companies will outperform. In Berkshire Hathaway’s 2013 shareholder letter, Buffett wrote that the typical investor does not need stock-picking expertise and can instead own a cross-section of businesses through a low-cost S&P 500 index fund. ¹ He also emphasized keeping costs low and avoiding the temptation to sell when markets decline.

Buffett reinforced the principle through a public 10-year wager pitting a low-cost S&P 500 index fund against five funds of hedge funds. His point was that identifying skilled managers in advance can be difficult and fees create an added hurdle.

An S&P 500 index fund generally takes the form of a mutual fund or exchange-traded fund that seeks to track the index rather than beat it. The S&P 500 contains 500 leading large-cap U.S. companies and covers about 80% of available U.S. market capitalization. It therefore offers broader company exposure than a concentrated investment portfolio, though it remains limited to large U.S. stocks.

Passive index funds also typically involve less active trading and often carry lower expenses than actively managed funds. However, costs vary by fund, and an index fund can still underperform its benchmark because of fees, trading costs and tracking error.

How $100,000 Could Grow in an S&P 500 Index Fund

Long-term compounding can increase the value of an investment substantially as gains build on earlier gains. Over several decades, different assumed rates of return can produce large differences in ending balances.

To calculate how a one-time investment could grow, investors can multiply the starting amount by one plus the assumed annual return, raised to the number of years the money remains invested. The calculation can be written as:

• Future value = Starting investment × (1 + annual return)^years

For a $100,000 investment held for 30 years, the calculation changes based on the assumed annual return. The table below shows the complete calculation at hypothetical returns of 6%, 8% and 10%.

These calculations break down the ending values, but comparing the balances at shorter intervals can also show how compounding builds over time. The next table tracks the same $100,000 investment in five-year increments under each return assumption.

These projections assume annual compounding, no additional contributions, no withdrawals, no taxes or investment fees, and reinvestment of all returns. At a hypothetical 8% annual return, $100,000 would grow to just over $1 million after 30 years without additional deposits.

The return assumption becomes increasingly important as the investment period gets longer. After 30 years, the spread between the 6% and 10% projections is:

• $1,744,940 − $574,349 = $1,170,591

Under these assumptions, the projected balance at 10% would be $1,170,591 higher than the balance at 6% after 30 years. Actual S&P 500 returns will vary from year to year and may be negative, particularly over shorter periods. An investor could therefore finish with substantially more or less than these estimates.

Buffett’s 90/10 Investment Strategy

Buffett’s support for index funds is also reflected in instructions he described for a trust benefiting his wife. In the same shareholder letter, he said the trustee should place 90% of the cash in a very low-cost S&P 500 index fund and 10% in short-term government bonds.

A stock-heavy allocation can provide long-term growth potential, while short-term government bonds may provide liquidity and reduce some portfolio volatility. But Buffett developed this 90/10 investment strategy for his family’s specific financial circumstances. It should not automatically be treated as an appropriate allocation for every investor.

A portfolio holding 90% stocks can experience substantial swings in value. Someone approaching retirement, making regular withdrawals, or uncomfortable with large losses may prefer a larger bond or cash allocation. Age matters, but so do income needs, other assets, risk tolerance and the number of years the money must remain invested.

Why Fees Matter for Long-Term Index Investors

Investment expenses reduce the amount left invested, and their effect can compound over time. The Securities and Exchange Commission notes that even seemingly small ongoing fees can have a significant long-term effect because investors lose both the fee itself and the future returns that money might have earned.

The following example compares two hypothetical portfolios that each start with $100,000 and earn 8% annually before fees. For simplicity, it assumes each expense ratio directly reduces the gross annual return and that there are no taxes, contributions, withdrawals or other costs.

For the portfolio with a 0.05% annual fee, subtracting the fee from the 8% return produces a hypothetical net annual return of 7.95%:

• 8% − 0.05% = 7.95%
• $100,000 × (1 + 0.0795)^30 = approximately $992,383

For the portfolio with a 1.00% annual fee, subtracting the fee from the 8% return produces a hypothetical net annual return of 7%:

• 8% − 1.00% = 7.00%
• $100,000 × (1 + 0.07)^30 = approximately $761,226

Using the rounded balances, the difference is:

• $992,383 − $761,226 = $231,157

Under these assumptions, the lower-cost portfolio ends with about $231,157 more. The 0.95-percentage-point fee difference may look small, but its effect accumulates throughout the 30-year period. Investors comparing index funds may therefore want to review expense ratios, transaction costs, account fees and tracking error.

What to Consider Before Following Buffett’s Strategy

An S&P 500 index fund can serve as a core stock holding, but it does not represent the entire investment market. It focuses on large U.S. companies, so it leaves out most international stocks, smaller U.S. companies and bonds.

Depending on an investor’s goals, a broader portfolio may include international stock funds, small- and mid-cap funds, bonds, cash, or other assets. These holdings may behave differently under various market conditions, although diversification cannot prevent losses.

Behavior also matters. Buffett has cautioned investors against reacting to market declines by selling stocks. An investor who cannot tolerate a major decline may have difficulty maintaining a stock-heavy allocation. Selling after prices fall can lock in losses and may cause the investor to miss part of a later recovery.

Before adopting the strategy, consider when the money will be needed, how much volatility is manageable and whether the portfolio must support retirement withdrawals. A financial advisor can help determine whether an S&P 500 index fund and a specific stock allocation fit an investor’s time horizon, risk tolerance, income needs, and retirement goals.

Bottom Line

Buffett’s index-fund guidance favors broad exposure, low costs and long holding periods over frequent trading or attempts to pick market winners. An S&P 500 fund may offer a simple foundation for long-term investing, but the 90/10 allocation is not universal. The appropriate mix depends on each investor’s financial circumstances and ability to remain invested during market declines.

Investment Planning Tips

• A financial advisor can help you determine how an S&P 500 index fund and bond allocation could fit into your long-term investment strategy. Finding a financial advisor doesn’t have to be hard. SmartAsset’s free tool matches you with vetted financial advisors who serve your area, and you can have a free introductory call with your advisor matches to decide which one you feel is right for you. If you’re ready to find an advisor who can help you achieve your financial goals, get started now.
• If you want to diversify your portfolio, here’s a roundup of 13 investments to consider.

Photo credit: ©iStock.com/phongphan5922, ©iStock.com/tadamichi