Loading
Tap on the profile icon to edit
your financial details.

NYC Real Estate One Year After Sandy

It’s been just over a year since Superstorm Sandy touched down in New York City but the effects are still being felt throughout the region.  Most of us were only able to experience the storm through photographs and news reports but it impacted the lives of millions of people.  Residents of NYC were left without power, gasoline, subway access and more for days to weeks to months and beyond.  Even schools and businesses were closed while the city tried to restore order in the days that followed the storm.

Wondering about your property tax?

NYC Real Estate One Year After Sandy

Obviously a storm like this will have a huge impact on the real estate market and this article will go into just how the recovery has been going using information from a recent StreetEasy report.

Immediate Impacts of Sandy

8136777567_2aef6c2027_z

The immediate impact of Sandy was felt to a varying degree depending on geography.  Communities near the coast like Brooklyn, Queens and Staten Island saw a significant decrease in closing activity and sale price while some areas of Manhattan were relatively unaffected.

NYC Real Estate One Year After Sandy

In the most flooded zones of Manhattan, transaction volume actually saw a 64% increase in the number of closings compared to the prior year, while other zones of Manhattan saw a 41% increase compared to the year before.  Meanwhile, in all of the outer boroughs, transaction volume declined in the immediate aftermath of Sandy.  Queens and Brooklyn saw the largest drops with 30% and 22% respectively compared to the year before.

The Recovery

Even though there were some large drops in transaction volume and sales prices in the outer boroughs, downtown was more an issue of supply and demand.  Areas like the Financial District and Seaport saw insane periods of activity less than a month after the storm had hit because there was still such high demand for housing in the area.  The median closing price for the Financial District has increased by 15% in September 2013 year over year.  This is explained by the fact that there’s not a lot of supply. Areas like this provide great value compared to other neighborhoods in the city.

Most real estate agents had assumed that uptown properties would surge after Sandy and downtown water-view properties would suffer.  But in the long run, the data actually shows the opposite: people are willing to pay a premium for downtown properties regardless of the threat of hurricanes.

By April 2013, six months after the storm, the Manhattan real estate market appeared to have completely rebounded.  There were 28% more contracts compared to the prior year and listings were spending 9% less time on the market.  By September 2013, the median asking price rose to 1.45 million, a 4% increase over the prior year.

What About Rentals?

In the immediate aftermath of Sandy, there was relatively little change in median asking rent in heavily affected areas.  However, we did see a 9% decrease in listings compared to the year prior.  This decrease is most likely explained by the logistical issues that moving would have caused immediately after the storm.  Simply put, it was very difficult to move so most people didn’t bother listing their properties.

Overall though, the rental market proved more resilient than the sales market for a couple reasons.  The rental market never really took a hit since so many people needed temporary housing.  In addition, renters have a lot less at stake investment-wise compared to a buyer.  The former has a much smaller investment in their property so there’s less risk than say buying a 2 million dollar property.

Photo Credit: kleepet; EUMETSAT; ccho; david_shankbone

Harry Campbell Harry Campbell is an aerospace engineer by day and personal finance blogger by night. He runs his own personal finance blog at Your PF Pro and is a freelance writer. Harry's expertise includes retirement, credit cards, home buying, higher education and side hustles like ridesharing. His work has been featured on Zillow, Credit Karma and CreditCards.com. Harry currently resides in Newport Beach, CA and enjoys biking and playing beach volleyball in his spare time.
Was this content helpful?
Thanks for your input!